Bridges vs. Implants: Which is the Best Choice for You?

illustration of a dental bridge vs dental implant

When it comes to replacing missing teeth, modern dentistry offers a range of solutions. Two of the most popular options are dental bridges and dental implants. Both have their own set of advantages and potential drawbacks, and the best choice often depends on individual circumstances and preferences. In this blog, we’ll delve into the key differences between bridges and implants, helping you make an informed decision about which is right for you.

What are Dental Bridges?

A dental bridge, as the name suggests, “bridges” the gap created by one or more missing teeth. It consists of two or more crowns for the teeth on either side of the gap (these two or more anchoring teeth are called abutment teeth) and a false tooth/teeth in between. The false teeth are called pontics and can be made from gold, alloys, porcelain, or a combination of these materials.

Types of Dental Bridges: 

There are four primary types of dental bridges, each designed to cater to specific needs and situations. Here’s a breakdown of the four types:

  1. Traditional Dental Bridges: Traditional bridges are the most common type of dental bridge. They consist of one or more pontics (false teeth) and are held in place by dental crowns. These dental crowns are cemented onto the teeth adjacent to the missing tooth or teeth, known as the abutment teeth. Pros of traditional bridges are that they are well-established and widely used, however they do require the removal of some tooth enamel from the surrounding teeth. 
  2. Cantilever Bridges: Unlike the traditional bridge, the cantilever bridge is held in place by a dental crown that is cemented to only one abutment tooth. This means that only one of the adjacent teeth needs to be prepared for the procedure. Pros of cantilever bridges are that only one tooth needs to be modified, however this type of bridge is less stable and can only be used in the front of the mouth. 
  3. Maryland Bonded Bridge: Maryland bridges are made of porcelain, porcelain fused to metal, or plastic teeth and gums supported by a metal or porcelain framework. Instead of using dental crowns on abutment teeth, this bridge uses metal or porcelain wings on each side of the bridge that are bonded to the back of the adjacent teeth. The pro of a Maryland bridge is that it doesn’t require modification of the surrounding teeth, however they are less durable than traditional bridges.
  4. Implant-Supported Bridges: As the name suggests, implant-supported bridges use dental implants for support instead of crowns or frameworks. Typically, one implant is surgically placed for every missing tooth, and these implants hold the bridge in position. If it’s not possible to place one implant for every missing tooth, the bridge might have a pontic suspended between two implant-supported crowns. The pros of an implant-supported bridge are the stability, appearance, and maintenance of the jawbone. However, the placement of implants requires oral surgery and is more time consuming than the other bridge types. 

Pros of Dental Bridges:

Here are the pros of dental bridges when compared to dental implants:

  • Quicker Process: The procedure for placing a dental bridge is generally faster than that for dental implants. Implants require a healing period after the implant post is placed into the jawbone, which can take several months, followed by another procedure to place the crown. Bridges, on the other hand, can often be completed in just a couple of visits.
  • No Surgery Required: Dental bridges are a non-surgical solution, whereas dental implants require a surgical procedure to place the implant into the jawbone. This can be especially beneficial for patients who are not good candidates for surgery or those who prefer to avoid it.
  • Cost: In many cases, dental bridges are less expensive upfront than dental implants. While the long-term costs might differ (bridges might need replacement after a certain number of years), the initial investment is often lower for bridges.
  • No Bone Grafting: Some patients who have experienced bone loss in the jaw are not immediate candidates for dental implants unless they undergo bone grafting. Dental bridges don’t require the jawbone for support, so bone grafting is not an issue.
  • Predictable Outcome: Dental bridges have been used for many years, and the procedure has a predictable outcome. While dental implants also have a high success rate, there’s a small chance of the body rejecting the implant or complications arising from the surgical procedure.
  • Immediate Aesthetic Improvement: Since the process for getting a bridge is quicker, patients can achieve an improved aesthetic appearance in a shorter time frame compared to waiting for an implant to heal.
  • Suitable for Certain Medical Conditions: Patients with certain medical conditions or who take specific medications might not be ideal candidates for implants due to potential complications or slower healing. In such cases, a bridge might be a more suitable option.

Cons of Dental Bridges:

While dental bridges offer several advantages, they also come with certain drawbacks, especially when compared to dental implants. Here are the cons of dental bridges in comparison to dental implants:

  • Impact on Adjacent Teeth: For a traditional dental bridge to be placed, the adjacent teeth on either side of the gap must be prepared, often requiring the removal of a significant amount of their enamel. This can weaken these teeth and make them more susceptible to decay and other issues.
  • Durability: Dental bridges, on average, have a lifespan of about 5-15 years, depending on care and oral hygiene. Dental implants, when properly cared for, can last a lifetime.
  • Bone Loss Prevention: Dental implants help in preserving the jawbone and preventing bone loss, as they replace the tooth root and provide stimulation to the bone. Dental bridges, on the other hand, do not provide this benefit, which can lead to the deterioration of the jawbone over time.
  • Oral Hygiene Challenges: Cleaning around and under a dental bridge can be more challenging than cleaning around natural teeth or dental implants. This can increase the risk of gum disease and tooth decay in the adjacent teeth.
  • Natural Feel and Function: Dental implants tend to feel and function more like natural teeth because they are anchored securely in the jawbone. Bridges, while functional, might not provide the same natural feel, especially when biting or chewing.
  • Potential for Recurring Treatments: Since bridges have a limited lifespan, they might need replacement or repair over time. This can lead to recurring dental treatments and associated costs.
  • Aesthetic Concerns: Over time, as the jawbone deteriorates beneath a bridge, there can be aesthetic concerns such as a sunken appearance of the mouth. Implants help maintain the jawbone’s integrity, preserving facial aesthetics.
  • Risk of Damage: The teeth supporting the bridge are at risk of damage or decay, especially if the bridge is not well-maintained. If one of the supporting teeth becomes compromised, the entire bridge can be affected.
  • Limited Support in Case of Multiple Missing Teeth: While bridges are effective for replacing one or a few missing teeth, they might not be the best solution for multiple missing teeth in different areas of the mouth. Implants can be more versatile in such scenarios.

What are Dental Implants?

Dental implants are titanium posts that are surgically positioned into the jawbone beneath the gum line. Once in place and bone surrounding the implant has had time to heal, a replacement tooth is then fixed to the post. The implant acts as a sturdy anchor, holding the replacement tooth in place.

Pros of Dental Implants:

Dental implants have become increasingly popular as a method for replacing missing teeth, and they offer several advantages over dental bridges. Here are the pros of dental implants when compared to dental bridges:

  • Natural Look and Feel: Dental implants are designed to mimic the root structure of natural teeth, providing a foundation for replacement teeth that look, feel, and function like your natural teeth.
  • Durability: With proper care and maintenance, dental implants can last a lifetime, making them a more permanent solution compared to dental bridges, which may need replacement after a certain number of years.
  • Bone Health Preservation: Dental implants help prevent bone loss in the jaw. When a tooth is lost, the lack of stimulation can lead to bone deterioration. Implants replace the tooth root, providing necessary stimulation to the jawbone and preventing bone resorption.
  • No Impact on Adjacent Teeth: Dental implants stand alone and do not rely on neighboring teeth for support. In contrast, traditional dental bridges require the adjacent teeth to be filed down to accommodate the bridge, potentially compromising their structural integrity.
  • Improved Oral Hygiene: Since dental implants function like natural teeth, they don’t present the same cleaning challenges as bridges. This makes it easier to maintain good oral hygiene, reducing the risk of tooth decay and gum disease.
  • Prevention of Facial Sagging: By preserving the jawbone’s integrity, dental implants help maintain the natural shape of the face. Over time, bone loss from missing teeth can lead to a sunken facial appearance, which implants can help prevent.
  • No Risk of Decay in the Implant: While the prosthetic tooth can’t decay, the natural teeth around a bridge can. An implant, being made of titanium, is not susceptible to cavities. However, it’s essential to maintain good gum health around the implant.
  • Versatility: Dental implants can be used to replace a single tooth, multiple teeth, or even an entire arch of teeth. They can also be used in conjunction with other dental prosthetics, such as dentures, to provide added stability.
  • Improved Chewing and Speaking: Because dental implants are anchored securely in the jawbone, they provide better chewing efficiency and clearer speech compared to some other tooth replacement options.
  • Long-Term Cost Efficiency: While the initial cost of dental implants can be higher than bridges, their durability and longevity can make them more cost-effective in the long run, as they may not require replacement or as many repairs.

Cons of Dental Implants:

Dental implants are a highly effective solution for tooth replacement, but they also come with certain drawbacks, especially when compared to dental bridges. Here are the cons of dental implants in comparison to dental bridges:

  • Surgical Procedure Required: Dental implants involve a surgical procedure to place the titanium post into the jawbone. This can be a deterrent for some individuals, especially those who are apprehensive about surgeries.
  • Longer Treatment Time: The dental implant process can be lengthy. After the implant is placed, there’s a healing period that can last several months before the final crown is attached. This is in contrast to dental bridges, which can often be completed in a couple of visits.
  • Higher Initial Cost: The upfront cost of dental implants is generally higher than that of dental bridges. While implants can be more cost-effective in the long run due to their durability, the initial investment is something to consider.
  • Potential for Complications: As with any surgical procedure, there’s a risk of complications such as infection, nerve damage, or sinus problems (if the implant is placed in the upper jaw).
  • Bone Health Requirements: For a dental implant to be successful, there needs to be sufficient bone in the jaw to support the implant. Patients with significant bone loss might require bone grafting, adding to the cost and duration of the treatment.
  • Not Always Covered by Insurance: Dental insurance plans vary, but many do not cover the full cost of dental implants, considering them a “cosmetic” procedure. This can make bridges a more financially appealing option for some individuals.
  • Potential for Implant Failure: While rare, there’s a possibility that the body might reject the dental implant or that it fails to integrate with the bone properly.
  • Age Considerations: Dental implants might not always be recommended for younger patients whose jaws are still growing or for elderly patients with certain health conditions.
  • Maintenance: While implants are resistant to decay, the gum tissue around them can become inflamed or infected if not properly cared for. Regular dental check-ups and good oral hygiene are essential.
  • Aesthetic Variability: Over time, the gum tissue around an implant can recede, potentially affecting the aesthetic appearance. While this can also happen with bridges, the design of some bridges might mask this effect better.

Making Your Decision

When deciding between a bridge and an implant, consider the following:

  • Oral Health: If you have healthy gums and sufficient bone to hold an implant, you might be a good candidate for the procedure.
  • Budget: Consider the long-term costs. While bridges might be less expensive upfront, they may need replacement in the future.
  • Aesthetics: Think about how you want your replacement tooth or teeth to look and feel.
  • Lifestyle: If you’re looking for a quicker solution without surgery, a bridge might be more appealing.

Lastly, it’s essential to consult with your dentist. They can provide personalized advice based on your oral health and individual needs. Remember, the goal is to restore function, maintain good oral health, and achieve a smile you’re proud of!

In Conclusion

In the journey of exploring tooth replacement options, both dental bridges and implants emerge as leading contenders, each with its unique set of advantages and challenges. While bridges offer a quicker, non-surgical solution that might be more budget-friendly upfront, implants promise longevity, natural feel, and the preservation of jawbone health. The decision between the two isn’t a one-size-fits-all answer but rather a deeply personal one, influenced by individual needs, oral health, financial considerations, and lifestyle preferences. Consulting with a dental professional is paramount in navigating this choice, ensuring that you select the solution that aligns best with your goals and offers a confident, radiant smile for years to come.

Continue to Learn More About Dentistry:



More from the Chestnut Dental Blog

dental file being used to clean out the inside of a tooth

Understanding Root Canal Treatment

Root canal treatment, often shrouded in myths and misconceptions, is a critical dental procedure aimed at saving and preserving teeth that have been severely damaged by decay or infection. Despite

Read More »